The Ideal 10 Star Rating System + Big Announcement!

At the end of this post I’ll be sharing an exciting announcement with you all, so be sure to get in on it!

I’ve always been pretty vocal about my dissatisfaction with Amazon’s five-star rating system for books, the main reason being that five stars seriously limits the flexibility I’m able to have while expressing my opinions. So I decided to take matters into my own hands and construct a template for a ten-star rating system.

Currently, Amazon suggests the following criteria:

1 Star = I hate it

2 Stars = I don’t like it

3 Stars = It’s okay

4 Stars = I like it

5 Stars = I love it

Yuck. So…basic. So pessimistic. It sounds more like one of those convenience YA protagonists monologuing about her crush than a respectable review system. Does anyone even follow those criteria? I don’t.

Allow me to propose the following ten-star reviewing method:

1 Star = I read two chapters, burst a blood vessel, and fed the book to my pet turtle Franklin II.

2 Stars = I read three chapters, got a headache, and shook my head disapprovingly in Franklin II’s general direction.

3 Stars = I finished the book, but frankly, Franklin II is more interesting. And he’s a turtle. He doesn’t do anything. And his food smells weird.

4 Stars = The book’s okay for some light entertainment if I’ve got nothing better to do. Unfortunately, Franklin II and I had a game of marbles scheduled for today, so I won’t be reading much. Franklin II is bad at marbles. This could take some time.

5 Stars = I don’t regret spending a few bucks on the ebook. I enjoyed the general story, but there wasn’t anything remarkable about it. I might recommend it to Franklin II, since, being a turtle, his literature standards are fairly low, but he’s more of a mystery novel chap.

6 Stars = It’ll probably find a spot on my shelf, assuming the cover looks nice. Franklin II is irrelevant now. He can’t even see the shelf.

7 Stars = I quite enjoyed the book. I tried to have a meaningful discussion about the character development with Franklin II, but he was chomping on a lettuce leaf quite rudely, so I got mad and left.

8 Stars = Hmm, impressive. This book really stands out, possibly enough to earn a spot near the top of the shelf, where over time it’ll acquire a Franklin II-esque aroma. Gross. Franklin II stinks.

9 Stars = I read this book out loud to Franklin II after I’d finished it. We both teared up at the end. I’ve never seen Franklin II get so emotional. It was a beautiful bonding experience.

10 Stars = This book is extraordinary. Franklin II and I built a shrine for it, and on the second Tuesday of each month, we spend ten minutes in contemplative awe in front of it. Sometimes we even split a potato chip.

I hope the King of Amazon sees this post and takes the necessary steps to make my method official. In the meantime, Franklin II escaped his tank again. Gotta go find him.

Okay, now for the big announcement!

After a week or so of careful consideration, consultation, and calibration, I’ve decided to start a Wattpad account and serialize one of my backburner novels. Whaaat? Yes. I know. I think the earth just shifted on its axis. Here’s a fancy shiny thing for you to look at and be amazed:

wattpad cover copy

A band of escaped slave children face a world that wants them back in chains…or dead. Their struggle for survival begins in the uncharted wilderness and ends in a city ready to tear itself apart.

Placeholder cover art by yours truly. 

So why take this project to Wattpad? Several reasons. I’ve been puttering away at the manuscript for the better part of five years now, never really prioritizing it, so I figure this will be a good way to stick with it and finish it. It’s also the only novel I’ve written that doesn’t follow a developed outline, so a weekly chapter system fits perfectly. Third, The Broken City of Crows is longer and more ‘traditional’ fantasy than what I usually write. Why not try something different for it? Lastly, I really like the idea of getting feedback from readers as we progress through the story.

The first two chapters of The Broken City of Crows are already posted on Wattpad. Go read them here and tell me what you think! Any shares, tweets, or promotional smoke signals are greatly appreciated as well.

From here on out I’ll be posting single chapters every Friday or Saturday (depending on which works better for potential readers). And yes, I’m still writing Where the Woods Grow in Flames, don’t worry!

Anyways, I’m really excited to try this out. I don’t have super high expectations, but I’m curious to see how far we can go! Any support from you guys means the world to me, so let’s get going. Come along, Franklin II. We’ll be late!

Have a great day, friends!


24 thoughts on “The Ideal 10 Star Rating System + Big Announcement!

  1. I really like your new rating system — especially the inclusion of Franklin and his input. Very smart to include a nonverbal being in your reading habits. Gives you better feedback, in some cases.

    Good luck with the Crows! (And, yeah, I can imagine people gathering outside your house with pitchforks if you don’t work more on the Woods sequel!)

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Be careful posting your work to Wattpad. I posted on Wattpad for three years, and most of the feedback is a joke. If anything, the readers there don’t care about supporting and helping the writer. Mostly, they just want a free story and then they move on.


    1. Good to know, thanks! I’ve heard a lot of positive things about the Wattpad community, but also some not-so-great things, so I’m kind of poking my toe in the water to see what happens.


    2. My issue with Wattpad was not only the lack of readerly interest, but also the spam emails I would get. Not 100% sure if that was just Wattpad or something else, yet the spam slowed down after I got off Wattpad.

      As a result, I want to read “The Broken City of Crows,” but I’m scared to go back on Wattpad! 😦

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Hmm, I hadn’t heard of that problem before. I haven’t received any emails from Wattpad beyond the regular notification emails, but I’ve only had my account for two or three days.


      2. I agree with you. It’s not the best place for writers, but the website masks itself as one. After I found out that readers can add unpublished, completed manuscripts from Wattpad to Goodreads and review them, I refuse to post my long works there. Not only is there poor readership, but the readers don’t care about the writers.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. This was hilarious. I’d give it 9-stars because I went and read it to my pet turtles (er… siblings, rather) and we got emotional (read: laughed very hard) over it. 😀

    Hope the Wattpad experiment goes well! I’m really bad at keeping up with any kind of serialized story (I do better bingeing an entire book in a day or two) but sounds interesting! (Also, nice cover. :D)

    Great post! Franklin II will live on in rating ideas for always now. (Also, Goodreads has a slightly better rating system — not quote so pessimistic — but I see what you mean.)


  4. “I might recommend it to Franklin II, since, being a turtle, his literature standards are fairly low, but he’s more of a mystery novel chap.” *crying with laughter*

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s